How to Feed a Lawyer (and Other Irreverent Observations from the Legal Underground)

    Click on the book cover for details!

« Goodbye, Ed | Main | Deposition Checklists and Strategies »


Saurabh Chandra

Regading the theory propogated by Malcom Gladwell in his Book " The Blink" , I wish to bring a few points in your kind notice :
According to Evan gladwell, when questions of analysis and personal choice start to get complicated - when we have to juggle many different variable (in the process of decision making) - then our unconcious thought process (intuitive repulsion or the Blink) may be superior. He further states that , decisions should be made on the basis of "this blink" as they are exact and correct. This principle has been reflected here in there in various religious/spiritual texts with no scientific evidences, records and approval. Even I found the author confused and failed to advocate his principal. Mearly quoting incidents, examples and experiments (some of which are not even relevant to intuitive repulsion) and concluding this principle has made it not acceptable . When the author presented this theory before the scholars of Haward Law school, he faced complete rejection.Intuitive repulsion is not universal and it occurs not very often. The world is entirely trained and habitual of making decisions based on calculations made by conscious brain, which selects an available option from the available options. Focus is on making these decisions more scientific.
Even if we keep this principle in the center of our hypothesis, It would be very difficult (not impossible but risky) to prove this hypothesis with traditional or existing scientific research mathodologies. It is risky to prove that a snap judgement can be far more effective than cautious decision, on the basis of statistical data, may be it can not be proved. just like the concept of God can not be proved scientifically. It can be proved theoratically but that would move beyond the lines of science and enter into the domain of ethics , most probably philosophy. Research methodology can be created. This research can also enter into the domain of religion, which can be quantitatively avaioded but can not qualitatively ignored. It would be interesting to prove it in India which is the mother of spirituality.
Some shades of existing decision making theories might touch this attribute of human mind, for which understanding and analysis of the theories would be required.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

About Evan Schaeffer

Search Beyond the Underground